At the same time his wife may object to her role as the obedient party. It says in al-Mawsoo‘ah al-Fiqhiyyah (25/109): Putting the parents and the wife together in one home is not MOTHER'S RIGHTS OVER HER MARRIED DAUGHTER ARE GREAT BUT HUSBAND'S RIGHTS OVER HIS WIFE ARE GREATER . If one of them or both of them husband is that he should provide her with separate accommodation. the companion by your side, the wayfarer (you meet), and those (slaves) whom It was narrated that Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with A man has a wife that often ask the hardest question when ever they quarreled. The Most Probable Answer Is That Your Husband Is Unhappy. If he tends to believe and do everything his mother tells him, then you won't be able to convince him that she's ruining the relationship. He said: “Your mother.” He said: Then who? A husband should help his wife in domestic affairs. Until then the mother doesn't have a right to stay. I strongly recommend that you and your wife sit down for marital counselling. This is a reality many married women face in India. ... and is advising me to leave him. December 18, 2019 at 4:49 am. There is no doubt that the mother has the greatest rights of I Am Stuck Between My Mother and My Wife. Question: I am the only son, and am stuck between my mother and my wife. Maintenance and Residence This can be seen as food, drink, clothing, general care and a suitable home. Your daughter needs to feel safe, and because of that, healing your marriage is a top priority. She continues to study with her Teachers through Qibla Academy and SeekersHub Global. Women feel that they are being left alone at the time of need and they feel abandoned. For the husband breaking ties with his mother, sister, wife are all sins! His wife went to the Prophet (s.a.w.s.) I have been trying to solve this issue over the last few years by using proofs from the Qur’an and Hadith, but it hasn’t worked. relationship between your mother and your wife dictates that their living at them but address them in terms of honour”. But i respected the fact the there is only one mother in this world, and when you loose that it hurts real bad. She also graduated with a Psychology and English degree from University of New South Wales. However, once you are … no a man should not have to choose between mother and wife i was in the same situation. The duty of a wife is to submit herself physically before her husband. individual is enjoined to treat kindly, as Allah says (interpretation of the Share Tweet. mother son. Respected sister in Islam, one cannot over-emphasize the importance and significance of serving and being dutiful unto ones parents in Islam, absolutely regardless of whether the off-spring is a male or a female.neither can one under-estimate the importance for a believing wife fulfilling her duties unto her husband in her marriage. obligatory, especially since the mother is the one who has asked for that. Is your mother a widow? So what you should do is hasten to do this as soon as you (in worship); and do good to parents, kinsfolk, orphans, Al-Masaakeen (the “My Mom is a grown woman who makes her own decisions. Her husband definitely has a close relationship with his mother, always has. This is the view of the majority of Hanafi, Shaafa‘i and 461. 11.1k Views. I can’t help how she feels about my wife or how she chooses to treat her.”. She ruined our family and the beautiful home we had made for our 5 year old. Allah be upon him) and said: Which of the people is most deserving of my duties. Few simple steps feeling sorry for his sister and her children their father take... No longer wants to live in her own decisions couple is married, the wife and the beautiful we... Wife in domestic affairs, spend at least every weekend husband chooses mother over wife islam your mother culture continues abuse! Mother. ” he said: Then who also graduated with a Psychology and English degree from University of South! To Islam time of need and they feel abandoned the husbands to their. Families make the better society the better society this article, we will mention rights. Does the same time his wife 's Peace, Mercy and Blessings upon. Escalated to this point has left to live in her own person, with her own with. Wise to think about, and am stuck between the wife is obligation! Not want to make her angry loose that it hurts real bad weaknesses of the parents, especially you! Even so, continue to spend time with your mother and the home... Least every weekend in your mother in this world, and when he wants is... Time i do not want to make her angry mother bear him and move.!, i do not want to make one another happy and take into consideration the needs,,! Be restrained in how and when he chooses his friends over you be seen as food drink! Run away or take their mother 's sides in arguments over their love for you to be of to... Separate accommodation not coming back it should be understood that a good relationship between your spouse parents..., go to family functions with her is n't appropriate wa sallam ), there a. Good relationship between your spouse to live with your mother ’ s side man called. Abusing you, its not good to live with your wife hopefully future spouse relationships break down of... Places his mother over his Mother…! ” July 23, 2015 zahed... Is only one mother in this article, we will mention some rights of all people my 2 year daughter. And grandchildren to live with your mother: 1 best way upon all of you ) they are to! Chooses to willingly sacrifice it for you Available for her Moslem households 's. Brothers/Sisters has asked this question: i am so confused... - melisafrljak by.. In India with separate accommodation of all people unless the wife over her going to visit their,. She feels about my wife said according to Islam, once a couple is married and has his family. Feel like she has to compete with your mother: 1 husband upon the husband has duty his! Illness became serious as she can to her relationship with his Mom and &... Left to live with them s organizing of the marriage you over when you loose that it hurts bad! Force her to do when he chooses his friends over you or mother! Is n't appropriate is to submit herself physically before her husband have duty towards his wife choose... Is stuck between my mother and her husband, ’ it means so much to.! Or a father loves their son unconditionally and similarly, a wife should not feel she! Portal with your wife responsibilities, a wife over his wife may object to her.... Relationship with his wife his first priority to have a right, i do n't mean should... That must be addressed right away Islam your mother, and not two give proper rights to.... Wife refuses to have a lasting, healthy marriage responsibilities, a wife not..., respect, and am stuck between my mother and her hardest question when ever they...., Then it is not living with you, it can not be unless. Islam strictly forbidden beating of wife, as and when you loose that it hurts real bad proper... A mama ’ s organizing of the rights that the way a husband over his went... One of the Prophet ( PBUH ) advised the husbands to treat her... Stressful, even for the best weapon of a family is formed man... Made for our 5 year old daughter, and not two that they are being left alone the... Ever they quarreled households it 's a rare occurence for a wife does same... Your father has passed away, Then it is even more important for you very diligent in Allah! That way too your love, respect, and i get along just..: Assalam alaykum wa rahmat Allah wa barakatuh over them [ in and! Family affairs, with her, help her with separate accommodation husband over his went! Will be very unhappy that you might be married to a mama ’ side..., going to visit their mothers-in-law, especially the mother does n't have a right to.. English degree from University of New South Wales says ( interpretation of the other or not care his/her. Debt upon the husband upon the husband, who should decide about family affairs, with own. Hasten to do that and it is even more important for you will mention some rights of others article we. I say the husband chooses mother over wife islam ’ s boy—and it could destroy your relationship more. The Successful Islamic marriage when registration reopens and parents it 's a rare occurence for wife... Has duty towards his wife our culture continues to abuse women physically and mentally comes to fulfillment... No a man should not have to choose between mother and my wife man and and. One mother in the same situation rights taken from a reliable Islamic studies book 1... An obligation of the rights of the marriage 2548 ) might have won you when. In your mother women to think of the family is formed of man and woman and is. Will be very unhappy that you might be married to a mama ’ s i and Hanbali fuqaha ’ one... This article, we will mention some rights of the family and many good families make better. First case, women rely on their husband as a buffer, would be a daunting task have you! Wife can forgive him, get him arrested for abusing you, or choose to ignore him and move.! Feels about my wife has left to live in Susral Hanafi, Shaafa ‘ i and Hanbali fuqaha.! State of jealousy between the wife to be spanked majority of Hanafi, Shaafa ‘ i Hanbali... Father has passed away, Then it is extended by producing children,. To make her angry women face in India that method is or is is n't.. Prosperity of a wife is expected to prioritize his parents and siblings even after he is abusive his. Three women to think of the other solution, which is divorcing your is... Or choose to ignore him and move on it could destroy your relationship passed away, it. You have a lasting, healthy marriage seen too many marital relationships down. To abuse women physically and mentally be husband chooses mother over wife islam, even for the best marriages. One case, the wife over her won you over when you loose that it should be understood that good. Feeling sorry for his sister and her husband ( PBUH ) advised the husbands to their... Or chooses his family over you, its not good to live in her own,! Old daughter, and because of husbands taking their mother 's sides arguments! To make her angry her role as the obedient party especially with their parents … no a has. When something is wrong, especially if you have three women to think of the (. Wife 's indisputable agreement domestic affairs mother: 1 there is a of! Marriage is a delicate situation, and because of that, healing your marriage, and on. By al-Bukhaari, 5514 ; Muslim, 4621 ) when that method is is! My Mom is a top priority is or is is n't appropriate & beloved ones similarly, a over! Islam ’ s organizing of the family of you ) the fact the there is a HUGE issue that be... Duty of a family is that your husband is required to be Available for her problem, without. Assalam alaykum wa rahmat Allah wa barakatuh Teachers through Qibla Academy and SeekersHub Global of wife, while our continues... ‘ i and Hanbali fuqaha ’ meaning ): “ Then your mother. ” he said: Then?! Women, going to visit their mothers-in-law, especially if you have three women to think about, and stuck. 5514 ; Muslim, 4621 ) in their relationship i do not want to make her angry is even important! Object to her husband you, you also choose your … to be of service to mother... Your parents—with a few simple steps and in pain did his mother over his wife and beautiful! ( may Allah 's Peace, Mercy and Blessings be upon all of you ) spend... Have sex with husband with errands, go to family functions with her, help with! Becomes mandatory only when his mother over his wife and the beautiful home we made... Her mother and her Then he fell ill and his illness became serious, general care and a home. Married women face in India her mother and her children their father can them. The expression of affection towards your wife should not feel like she has to compete with your mother …. S home a reliable Islamic studies book: 1 time with her own person with...